Six More

2666, Roberto Bolaño

I put this one on my list* because I read online somewhere (probably NYT, NYRB, or the New Yorker… for someone who’s never lived in New York I sure need to diversify my media consumption) that Bolaño is the best thing since sliced bread. Or maybe it was James Joyce. In any event, 2666 went on my list and it turns out my local library had it. Well, 2666 falls under the category “I read it so you don’t have to”; that is: skip it. It consists of five tangentially related books, each of which is about five times too long. I only enjoyed the last one, and that was probably because I was no longer reading a horribly depressing and repetitive recounting of feminicide in northern Mexico. I’m sure there’s lots of great symbolism and such about the decay of modern society in there, but unless you are an English major (or Spanish major, I guess) or have a companion book and a lot of time, just move on. I still have no idea what the number 2666 has to do with anything.

The Mists of Avalon, Marion Zimmer Bradley

While also rather long, this one falls at the other end of the complexity spectrum of 2666. (Well, it’s not a children’s book, that is, but it is a fantasy novel.) Marion Zimmer Bradley first came to my attention years ago as one of Michael D.C. Drout’s “worthy successors to Tolkein”, and weeks ago it happened to be on display at my library. She provides a feminist (or at least female-centric) interpretation of the Arthurian cycle, and–despite my quip to Anna one night that it mostly consists of “women herb-ing each other left, right, and center”–it is definitely worth your time, if you are at all interested in King Arthur specifically or fantasy literature in general.

Look to Windward, Iain M. Banks

Another Iain M. Banks science fiction novel, this one tells the story of two war veterans, one of a “good war” (I think) that calls to mind the contemporary view of World War Two, and the other of a civil war caused by external influence, which seemed to me to be a sort of commentary on the (most recent) Iraq War. While I don’t think it’s the most insightful commentary on the experiences of the modern veteran (for more on that, see the next book report post), it does manage to comment well on the human condition. As an aside, this is the second time I’ve read this book, because I accidentally got it from the library, not realizing I’d read it before. I suppose that’s either a negative comment on the book’s memorability or a positive comment on its quality–probably both. In any event, I do recommend Iain M. Banks’ science fiction to all, starting with The Algebraist and moving on to the Culture series (of which this is a part).

Half of a Yellow Sun, Chimamanda Ngozie Adichie

The unquestionable winner of this round-up, Half of a Yellow Sun follows three characters through the Nigerian Civil War. You should go and read this book right now. It is, of course, something of a downer–there’s always a certain tragedy accompanying defeat in a civil war / war of independence (except for the American Civil War, don’t get me started), and this novel provides both that, and the tragedy common to civilians in all wars, in spades. Still, you should read this book, now. It was recommended to me by the same friend who recommended The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao, last time’s winner, so maybe he’s onto something.

The Sleepwalkers: How Europe Went to War in 1914, Christopher Clark

The Guns at Last Light: The War in Western Europe, 1944-1945, Rick Atkinson

These shouldn’t really be subject to a joint review, seeing as they cover different subjects, but they’re both military/political history and I read them sequentially** so this is as close of an opportunity as I’m ever going to get so here goes. The Sleepwalkers covers the political, military, economic, and diplomatic situation in Europe in the beginning of the 20th century leading up to the start of the First World War. I saw it recommended (again, somewhere online–no doubt as part of a 100-year retrospective) as a thorough exploration of the roots of the war; its thesis is that there is no single person, nation, or alliance accountable for the war but that the nations of Europe stumbled–or rather, sleepwalked–into it. I only got through about half of it before someone put a hold on it and I had to return it to the library, but it certainly seemed to do a pretty good job setting up that claim; incidentally, I now know more about the economy and politics of Serbia in 1910 than I really wanted to (it’s a rather academic book). I do intend to finish it, someday.

The Guns at Last Light, by contrast, is definitely a popular history. There’s a lot more of “…he must have thought, as he gazed out over the ____ [assembled troops, windswept plain, etc]” and general America-(and-Britain)-is-great-this-is-the-good-war kind of stuff. Nevertheless it does provide a view from the level of both the commanders (mostly Eisenhower, decent amount of Montgomery, and so on) and the common soldier. (It is also a much quicker read than The Sleepwalkers.) If you’re interested in military history–or think you might be–then definitely check out Rick Atkinson, starting with “An Army at Dawn”. (As an aside: Atkinson is much, much better than Stephen E. Ambrose–Ambrose might as well have titled his books “Hoo-rah”, so just watch HBO’s Band of Brothers (which I do recommend) instead.)

* “My list” is a bit of web software I put together for fun. The source is available here, though there’s probably a bit of work to do before others can easily set it up for themselves. (And something like Goodreads is probably better, though I prefer to keep my data to myself.)

** I did read them sequentially, but in parallel with the fiction on this list. Generally I have an “upstairs book” (fiction, bedside) and a “downstairs book” (nonfiction, morning/weekend) going simultaneously. More information than you wanted, but that’s what blogs are for, right? (My downstairs book will soon again be Bertrand Russell, for the amusement of those who follow me on twitter.)

2 thoughts on “Six More

  1. I know people on Tumblr that would physically attack you for this comment on 2666, but I have to say I read some of his other stuff and was similarly unimpressed. Got in a spat about it with a professor at HF who is also sitting on the Watson committee this year (he does Spanish literature) – I didn’t like the NYer Bolano pieces I read as part of my archive-devouring. John Ivey never shuts up about Half of a Yellow Sun (it’s a movie now, right?), and also I think he never finished Mists of Avalon but he was reading it all summer.

    I started The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao based on your last post and it’s probably been my best decision since starting grad school. Up next: entire Le Carre corpus.

    Anna, if you’re reading this, I would LOVE some Fall-ish, Thanksgiving-ish recipes. I suppose your SoCal weather helps transcend the plebeian East Coast yearnings for pumpkin et al but I have a full kitchen again!

    • I’m 100% certain that I essentially missed the point of 2666. I really probably would have enjoyed it if I had had a companion reader to go along with it. But, frankly, I’m a grad student in physics, not literature, so I don’t have the energy for that. The book should either be a lot clearer or 1/5th the length. (Preferably both.)

      I think a lot of people feel the same way about James Joyce. I rather enjoy Joyce–partly no doubt because I am destined to–but also because I think his command of language is unrivaled. Since I’m reading Bolano in translation, though, that’s something I’ll miss out on.

      I believe Half of a Yellow Sun is a movie, which I know only because I saw a bunch of stills from it when I was searching for the book cover. You really should give the book a shot if you aren’t put off by depressing literature (don’t you have a think for Kierkegaard?). As far as Mists of Avalon goes, you really get the idea for what’s going on once you get into the main part of the story (i.e. after the part with the whiny Igraine), so you can start speeding up–or at least that’s what I did.

      I’m not sure what you mean by “best decision since starting grad school”. Surely you only mean to use that as a temporal marker? That is, I hope you’re not comparing your decision to start Wao with your decision to start grad school and finding the latter to be better… or maybe I should just give up and go to your grad school!

      Also, for le Carre, well, I’d be happy to rank them for you (I think I did so on twitter a while ago), but this reply is already practically longer than the post so I’ll just say that the best starting place is probably “The Spy Who Came in from the Cold” and leave it at that.

      As for fall foods, yes, my dearly beloved has been corrupted by the ease of the weather here, but she has never lost her love for fall foods. I’ll try to get her to post some for you.

      P.S. Thanks for the comment!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s